By David Hackett Fischer
"If one laughs whilst David Hackett Fischer sits right down to play, one will remain to cheer. His booklet needs to be learn 3 times: the 1st in anger, the srcond in laughter, the 3rd in respect....The knowledge is expressed with a certin ruthlessness. Scarcly an enormous historian escapes unscathed. 10000 individuals of the AmericanHistorical organization will rush to the index and breathe a bit more straightforward to discover their names absent.
Read Online or Download Historians' Fallacies : Toward a Logic of Historical Thought PDF
Best historiography books
Three maps Joseph A. Amato proposes a daring and cutting edge method of writing neighborhood heritage during this innovative, wide-ranging, and deeply attractive exploration of the which means of position and residential. Arguing that folks of each position and time deserve a background, Amato attracts on his heritage as a eu cultural historian and a prolific author of neighborhood background to discover such issues because the heritage of cleanliness, sound, anger, insanity, the clandestine, and the surroundings in southwestern Minnesota.
Richard Hofstadter (1916-70) used to be America’s such a lot wonderful historian of the 20 th century. the writer of numerous groundbreaking books, together with the yank Political culture, he was once a full of life champion of the liberal politics that emerged from the recent Deal. in the course of his approximately thirty-year occupation, Hofstadter fought public campaigns opposed to liberalism’s so much dynamic rivals, from McCarthy within the Nineteen Fifties to Barry Goldwater and the sunlight Belt conservatives within the Nineteen Sixties.
Whereas an exile from Constantinople, the twelfth-century Byzantine functionary and canonist John Zonaras culled past chronicles and histories to compose an account of occasions from construction to the reign of Alexius Comnenus. For issues where his resources are misplaced or seem in other places in additional truncated form, his testimony and the identity of the texts on which he relies are of serious significance.
Carr's goal is to stipulate a distinctively phenomenological method of historical past. heritage is mostly linked to social lifestyles and its previous, and hence his inquiry makes a speciality of our adventure of the social global and of its temporality. How does heritage bridge the space which separates it from its item, the prior?
- Three Ways to Be Alien: Travails and Encounters in the Early Modern World (The Menahem Stern Jerusalem Lectures)
- Comparing the Incomparable (Cultural Memory in the Present)
- Frames of Memory after 9/11: Culture, Criticism, Politics, and Law
- Fashioning History: Current Practices and Principles
Additional resources for Historians' Fallacies : Toward a Logic of Historical Thought
There is much to be salvaged from the wreckage-a zeal for quantification of historical problems, a determination to make questions and assumptions explicit, and an impressive conceptual sophistication. But Fogel's inquiry is flawed by three fatal inconsistencies : First, his evidence of a transportation net which might have operated in the · absence of railroads is necessarily derived from a world in which railroads were present. Fogel tries to allow for this bias in his material, but only by introducing other fictional constructs which assume what he promises to prove by empirical inquiry.
Carr believes that the in ev itabil i ty problem "attaches itself almost exclusively to contemporary h isto ry . ' I am sure it was intended as a perfectly serious talk. ' you would at once have suspected some joke. The historian writes of the Norman conquest or the American war of independence as if what happened was in fact bound to happen, and as if it was his business simply to e xpl ai n what happened and w hy " ( ibid. ) . But this, unfortunately, is no t true, at least as far as the American Revolution is concerned.
The working historian, in my opinion, is well advised to deal with these dilemmas by a method of indifference. 20 Some historians of a humanist bent will protest that all historical problems are metaphysical problems. This is humbug. It can be argued that all historical problems can be made into metaphysical problems if 1 6. , "The Causes of the Ci vil War : A Note on Historical Sentimen tal i sm , " Partisan Review 16 ( 1 949 ) : 980. 17. P i ete r Geyl, "The American Civil War and the Problem of Inevi ta bi l ity ," Debates with Historians ( New York, 1958 ) , p.